Sybil farm: WAL claims
The case file identifies 24 WAL claimants that sent their allocations to one collector in March 2025. The following calls compare their first funders with those of other claimants.
Sources
Section titled “Sources”- Walrus, WAL mainnet NFT airdrop
- Bybit, proof-of-reserves audit, which lists the reserve wallet the collected WAL reached
- Case file:
walrus-wal-claim-farm-2025-03.json, which lists all 24 wallets
The case file documents the claim and transfer transactions for these wallets. Common control is the inference being tested.
| Subject | Value |
|---|---|
| Collector | 0xfbf58484139c8ace65aef5a52d3615ce0331bd4c80f4641a286d22b3fc9abd05 |
| One farm wallet | 0x07d047d215228bc979f568a2504b87e0ac6d64d09681bf9e868ff9cee6feef83 |
| Shared funder | 0xb43139646d70b02e44dd5c16af587197e693b3197ebbcb60a750d03d82abfaa5 |
| WAL claim event | 0x98af8b8fde88f3c4bdf0fcedcf9afee7d10f66d480b74fb5a3a2e23dc7f5a564::events::NFTWithdrawal |
query_events can inspect the claim records before sampling:
{ "event_type": "0x98af8b8fde88f3c4bdf0fcedcf9afee7d10f66d480b74fb5a3a2e23dc7f5a564::events::NFTWithdrawal", "after_checkpoint": "2025-03-27T10:00:00Z", "before_checkpoint": "2025-03-27T10:30:00Z" }The response lists decoded events with sender, emitting_module and
tx_digest. event_type filters by the defining struct; the separate
module argument filters the emitting call, which can be in another module.
Pass next_cursor as cursor with the same filters and order while
has_next_page is true. A short or empty service read does not by itself
mean the event list has ended.
1. See who paid the collector
Section titled “1. See who paid the collector”summarize_address_flows
on the collector for the three days after claims opened:
{ "address": "0xfbf58484139c8ace65aef5a52d3615ce0331bd4c80f4641a286d22b3fc9abd05", "from": "2025-03-27T00:00:00Z", "to": "2025-03-30T00:00:00Z" }"coverage": { "scanned_transactions": 25, "complete": true, … },"coins": [ { …, "symbol": "WAL", …, "in": 19968, "out": 19968, …, "transactions_in": 24, "transactions_out": 1, … } ],"inflow_source_count": 24,"top_recipients": [ { "address": "0x60dd01bc037e2c1ea2aaf02187701f9f4453ba323338d2f2f521957065b0984d", "label": "Bybit reserve wallet", "coins": [ { "symbol": "WAL", "amount": 19968, … } ], "digests": [ "4vjL1u67iiGDtHN2vv1fXcV4N28GTXcL85zEfHT9rmmE" ], "first_at": "2025-03-29T10:27:10.387Z", … }]The collector received 19,968 WAL from 24 addresses and sent 19,968 WAL to a wallet listed in Bybit’s proof of reserves.
2. Confirm one wallet claimed and swept
Section titled “2. Confirm one wallet claimed and swept”summarize_address_flows
on one of the 24:
{ "address": "0x07d047d215228bc979f568a2504b87e0ac6d64d09681bf9e868ff9cee6feef83", "from": "2025-03-27T00:00:00Z", "to": "2025-04-14T00:00:00Z" }"coins": [ { …, "symbol": "WAL", …, "in": 590, "out": 590, … } ],"unattributed_inflows": [ { "symbol": "WAL", …, "amount": 590, …, "digests": [ "CNnW3M8H4vzBmCm1Piaavg8TEWkuzhHLFpXGJMPnxmGY" ] }],"top_recipients": [ { "address": "0xfbf58484139c8ace65aef5a52d3615ce0331bd4c80f4641a286d22b3fc9abd05", "coins": [ { "symbol": "WAL", "amount": 590, … } ], "digests": [ "3doBwS5jmXZhtQynPaF1jy2XrcgM2HFyHC2CfNHoTzLk" ], "first_at": "2025-03-27T10:01:22.427Z", … }]CNnW3M8H… credited this wallet 590 WAL without a sending address.
The wallet sent 590 WAL to the collector about 80 seconds later.
3. Look for a shared funder
Section titled “3. Look for a shared funder”find_funding_sources
over all 24 wallets:
{ "addresses": [ "0x07d047d215228bc979f568a2504b87e0ac6d64d09681bf9e868ff9cee6feef83", "0x08826bca504e92b87180ef89907aed340e8e384ca59681b46c5e441ffc68442f", "0x0dad38bae3c047c5a70388ce2ba30fcebdb6b669507ff91ed940f61828c24904", "0x102d9805c71455dcb877cd29c1934c57db0b5afc742295ca98b454e5608ec876", "0x33831a12d1915ab7cf3ef001be1a692f641bcb520fc62301a8c085144af5bed6", "0x3b559aff5ae1a792c820b7f12f13e51755ccb3005b6fc39e871692ff81938677", "0x3c825ab8920017b173ee8660ee98654a12e0503fe809114532e2b61351bd6f35", "0x5323d8ca69bd5fb79aa0e66e855ade83722e743443a79f973d6c2fbbeb869ec9", "0x5b7ad2ac464f27a21fe9b73e4724fff6b2a6935acc7057fc4427b28b46ee21b9", "0x7349e5ca20f93941d36233ba9c6389701dc27aed9eeda149b9d15cbeac3e9ce7", "0x76a04ca24439656ccb423046bba4f0cdd67ba21f628057434508e302055a2750", "0x78747d586099be058af2af741db21a29c6d7ae3dc74f33894cf80d30916443c6", "0x86427087eece4817cce92c6e9ea0bba2755208169457ba68b1bf70ba6dd315d5", "0x8f87ab650920b33e23809ffbf0024b2be803e217ae9aa01333465fda665ee4c9", "0x9ac89a22dc6ef608d4da1f81dbfd8273cbe06892a27e85b489539f19aefb9db3", "0x9ed495338be7b0717277f799c3e9f636197b9deeba2d8eb318665199ed87f4ae", "0xa01824e21ba8681436bab9b7cccd392d374015f5633de77fa9bb478bc44a7af2", "0xbdd7063aa728563167d446ba15b7d4382b38c30691faab45da6f0eba20d87352", "0xbe2ab94a20c863d016ff27a8b514309e97e15c2e49ea1b49ba8929816c7564e9", "0xc2cda716e17a04ec5b5ef1876c72648eb0e9edbf1b96c147de09810527d4bcfa", "0xc2de996a383294877f1dbad59cb0b995058eb85b364d1eb2b879135e3d322865", "0xc34033c294b4666c1d29d96d1309debd2f3774ad1878eee8f274042b36a6f674", "0xc85073696bbe994a6feae3e3ce20e26ffb2225178db8ffbd8158a2579bf22d8c", "0xf266f8569e056435346dd6d2fa7abfa6dfa36725e97a6f6d24961e7f2a358813"], "depth": "first_hop" }"shared_funders": [ { "funder": "0xb43139646d70b02e44dd5c16af587197e693b3197ebbcb60a750d03d82abfaa5", "funded_count": 24, "funded": [ "0x07d047d215228bc979f568a2504b87e0ac6d64d09681bf9e868ff9cee6feef83", … ], "funder_popularity": { "popular": true, … }, "fanout": { … } }],"funding_bursts": [ … { "started_at": "2024-05-19T08:23:30.373Z", "ended_at": "2024-05-19T08:26:13.641Z", "addresses": [ "0x07d047d215228bc979f568a2504b87e0ac6d64d09681bf9e868ff9cee6feef83", … ], "funders": [ "0xb43139646d70b02e44dd5c16af587197e693b3197ebbcb60a750d03d82abfaa5" ], "single_funder": true, … }, …],"results": [ { "address": "0x07d047d215228bc979f568a2504b87e0ac6d64d09681bf9e868ff9cee6feef83", "first_funder": "0xb43139646d70b02e44dd5c16af587197e693b3197ebbcb60a750d03d82abfaa5", "first_hop": { "funding_tx": "Hc5KdsNToXab2b7m925uripuU1N2yQrzkPtX6RHB5vux", "timestamp": "2024-05-19T08:23:30.373Z", "amount": "0.3 SUI", … }, … }, …]The first SUI payment to each of the 24 wallets came from the same funder
between 08:23 and 08:35 UTC on 19 May 2024, in the bursts funding_bursts
lists. popular: true means that address also funded many others, so common
funding through it does not establish common control on its own.
4. Draw a control group
Section titled “4. Draw a control group”sample_control_addresses
from the same claim event in the same half hour, excluding the 24:
{ "event_type": "0x98af8b8fde88f3c4bdf0fcedcf9afee7d10f66d480b74fb5a3a2e23dc7f5a564::events::NFTWithdrawal", "size": 24, "exclude": [ "0x07d047d215228bc979f568a2504b87e0ac6d64d09681bf9e868ff9cee6feef83", "0x08826bca504e92b87180ef89907aed340e8e384ca59681b46c5e441ffc68442f", "0x0dad38bae3c047c5a70388ce2ba30fcebdb6b669507ff91ed940f61828c24904", "0x102d9805c71455dcb877cd29c1934c57db0b5afc742295ca98b454e5608ec876", "0x33831a12d1915ab7cf3ef001be1a692f641bcb520fc62301a8c085144af5bed6", "0x3b559aff5ae1a792c820b7f12f13e51755ccb3005b6fc39e871692ff81938677", "0x3c825ab8920017b173ee8660ee98654a12e0503fe809114532e2b61351bd6f35", "0x5323d8ca69bd5fb79aa0e66e855ade83722e743443a79f973d6c2fbbeb869ec9", "0x5b7ad2ac464f27a21fe9b73e4724fff6b2a6935acc7057fc4427b28b46ee21b9", "0x7349e5ca20f93941d36233ba9c6389701dc27aed9eeda149b9d15cbeac3e9ce7", "0x76a04ca24439656ccb423046bba4f0cdd67ba21f628057434508e302055a2750", "0x78747d586099be058af2af741db21a29c6d7ae3dc74f33894cf80d30916443c6", "0x86427087eece4817cce92c6e9ea0bba2755208169457ba68b1bf70ba6dd315d5", "0x8f87ab650920b33e23809ffbf0024b2be803e217ae9aa01333465fda665ee4c9", "0x9ac89a22dc6ef608d4da1f81dbfd8273cbe06892a27e85b489539f19aefb9db3", "0x9ed495338be7b0717277f799c3e9f636197b9deeba2d8eb318665199ed87f4ae", "0xa01824e21ba8681436bab9b7cccd392d374015f5633de77fa9bb478bc44a7af2", "0xbdd7063aa728563167d446ba15b7d4382b38c30691faab45da6f0eba20d87352", "0xbe2ab94a20c863d016ff27a8b514309e97e15c2e49ea1b49ba8929816c7564e9", "0xc2cda716e17a04ec5b5ef1876c72648eb0e9edbf1b96c147de09810527d4bcfa", "0xc2de996a383294877f1dbad59cb0b995058eb85b364d1eb2b879135e3d322865", "0xc34033c294b4666c1d29d96d1309debd2f3774ad1878eee8f274042b36a6f674", "0xc85073696bbe994a6feae3e3ce20e26ffb2225178db8ffbd8158a2579bf22d8c", "0xf266f8569e056435346dd6d2fa7abfa6dfa36725e97a6f6d24961e7f2a358813" ], "from": "2025-03-27T10:00:00Z", "to": "2025-03-27T10:30:00Z", "seed": 20250327 }"addresses": [ … ],"events_scanned": 5000,"population_truncated": true,"population_size": 4990,"requested": 24,"seed": 20250327,"undersampled": false,…The seeded sample selects other event senders in the specified window
among the 5,000 events scanned. The population scan was truncated, so
this draw cannot establish coverage of every claimant in the window.
Record and pass its addresses to the next call; the seed makes the draw
reproducible from that scanned population.
5. Run the same funding test on the control
Section titled “5. Run the same funding test on the control”find_funding_sources
over the 24 addresses returned by step 4, with depth: "first_hop".
Use the complete returned addresses array as the addresses argument.
"shared_funders": [ { "funder_popularity": { "popular": true, … }, … }, { "funder": "0x60dd01bc037e2c1ea2aaf02187701f9f4453ba323338d2f2f521957065b0984d", … }],…The case check found no funding_bursts or co_funded_in_one_transaction
in this sample. Neither shared funder is classified as narrow. One is a
Bybit reserve wallet; the other is a high-fanout distributor. A different
seed produces a different control sample.
6. Classify the collector
Section titled “6. Classify the collector”classify_deposit_address
on the collector:
{ "address": "0xfbf58484139c8ace65aef5a52d3615ce0331bd4c80f4641a286d22b3fc9abd05" }"verdict": "likely","tier": "heuristic","hot_wallet": "0x60dd01bc037e2c1ea2aaf02187701f9f4453ba323338d2f2f521957065b0984d","exchange": { "label": "Bybit reserve wallet", "entity": "Bybit", "evidence": "proof-of-reserves-listed", … },"checks": { "single_destination": true, "full_balance_sweeps": true, …, "destination_is_exchange": true },"sweeps": [ { "digest": "4vjL1u67iiGDtHN2vv1fXcV4N28GTXcL85zEfHT9rmmE", … } ]The classifier reports likely and tier: "heuristic" after reading
the collector’s full-balance transfer to the labelled Bybit reserve
wallet. The chain does not identify the account holder at Bybit.
The classifier reads every balance-change page before checking destinations or
reconstructing balances. If a continuation cannot be read, it returns
verdict: "unknown", lists the digests in incomplete_transactions, and leaves
every check null with an explanation in checks_not_run. Sweep and deposit
counts are null, and window_complete is false. The deposit check in
get_address_fanout carries the same unknown verdict and incomplete-read reason.
The inferred-label sync reads complete balance-change connections for
candidate addresses and exchange wallets. An incomplete read prevents
npm run sync:labels from replacing its label file.
Evidence and limits
Section titled “Evidence and limits”- The claims, transfers and first-funding transactions are chain facts. Shared operation is an inference: one address first funded all 24 cohort wallets within 12 minutes, while the recorded control sample has no funding burst and its shared funders are an exchange reserve wallet and a distributor.
- The control draw comes from a truncated event scan, so some claimants may fall outside its population. A different seed gives a different sample from that scan; run more than one before relying on the rate.
- The deposit-address verdict is a heuristic. It says who runs the destination wallet, not who the account holder is. Only the exchange can name the account.
- Wallets that share nothing with the cohort are not cleared. A farm that funds each wallet from a different exchange withdrawal would not show up in step 3.
Related
Section titled “Related”- Gas sponsors: the other shared-infrastructure
signal,
sponsor_shapefromget_address_fanout. - Fund flows:
find_flow_pathconfirms the path from a farm wallet to the reserve wallet in two hops. - Forensics skill: the order to work in and the conclusions to refuse.